Fishing The Fly Scotland Forum
 

Today's Featured Forum Photo

Picking your next rod?

Started by Keith Potter, 11/07/2025 at 19:40

Keith Potter

So how do you pick your next rod purchase?

I recently bought myself a nice new rod but just can't get on with it. It's 9ft 5wt same as my older rod is for fishing the hill lochs but I just can't get the new rod to cast a decent line. Tried 3 different lines and about to go up a line weight to see if it would load better but considering just selling it for something else so looking to see what tips folk have on selecting a new rod.
Thanks

James Laraway

like many folk here I'm on glass now, the only disadvantage being 8ft is the max length in glass. I like them for the brownies as they bend even with smaller fish. Do you fish bank or boat? Is your casting stroke relaxed or do you like a fast rod?

Robert MacDonald-Lewis

My preference is to try before I buy but that is often difficult or next to impossible. For the last few rods I have bought or built I have relied headily on recommendations from friends. This can obviously be a bit hit amd miss but has worked for me so far.

I feel that part of the problem trying and choosing a rod is that the line used can have a huge impact on the feel of the rod.

Relative price of the rod and lines may drive the best option for you, either changing the rod or trying other lines.

Keith Potter

Quote from: James Laraway on 12/07/2025 at 02:36like many folk here I'm on glass now, the only disadvantage being 8ft is the max length in glass. I like them for the brownies as they bend even with smaller fish. Do you fish bank or boat? Is your casting stroke relaxed or do you like a fast rod?

Mostly fish from the bank with only the odd day in the boat. Have been tempted with a glass rod but it seems another minefield full of options.😂😂

James Laraway

Quote from: Keith Potter on 22/07/2025 at 21:36Mostly fish from the bank with only the odd day in the boat. Have been tempted with a glass rod but it seems another minefield full of options.😂😂

Where are you based Keith?

Keith Potter

Quote from: James Laraway on 23/07/2025 at 11:25Where are you based Keith?

I'm just outside Oban over on the west coast.

James Laraway

Quote from: Keith Potter on 24/07/2025 at 11:44I'm just outside Oban over on the west coast.


i was going to say if you were more over inverness way i could give you a cast with a couple of glass rods...

Keith Potter

Quote from: James Laraway on 24/07/2025 at 13:56i was going to say if you were more over inverness way i could give you a cast with a couple of glass rods...

That's very kind of you. Might be heading over to contin with work soon so might take you up on that offer.

James Laraway

Just let me know when your across and we can see if we can meet up?

David Thursz

Good evening
What Rod is causing the problem?

Keith Potter

Quote from: David Thursz on 31/08/2025 at 21:04Good evening
What Rod is causing the problem?

It's a Orvis Clearwater that I'm slowly getting used to. Have went onto a #6 floating line and finally feel like it's actually working a bit better.

Peter Lister

A few years ago I had a holiday in the Borders (Kelso) I had a day fishing the Teviot+Tweed for trout+grayling with kit hired from the Orvis shop in Kelso.I was Hooked ( *smiley-wink* ) not having Fly Fished since I was a teenager I decided to get a Fly Rod made for a xmas treat for myself, after a few months researching I decided on a Leighton  9'6" Trout Rod from a Chas Burns who comes from York area, he used to have a Tackle shop in York but closed it after the big floods a few years back.I used it a few times and found it very nice to use. I recently joined a Angling  club at work and have been out alot more this year with my rod and I am thoroughly enjoying the Fly Fishing mainly at fisheries within an hours drive form Glasgow..where I work and live.

I recently purchased a Switch Rod  Package from Guideline as we have a few Salmon Trips coming up and as I have never had double handed rod before I thought it best get some training from a Professional, I had 2 hours training with Andrew Toft a former Spey Casting world champion from 2010 and had a good session with him, he went over the basics of fly fishing with my trout rod which he said was very well balanced and the double handed basics as well. I am now looking forward to our Salmon river trips and I am hoping to have a few more hours with Andrew Toft next season to increase my knowledge of the two handed Fly Fishing .. I used to like a bit of sea fishing as well but haven't been for years..seemingly Fly Fishing is also on the up at sea..


Barrio Fly Lines - designed in Scotland - Cast with confidence all over the world

Barrio Fly Lines

Designed in Scotland

Manufactured in the UK

Cast with confidence all over the world

www.flylineshop.com