Fishing The Fly Scotland Forum
 

Today's Featured Forum Photo

AI in flyfishing and flytying

Started by Robert MacDonald-Lewis, 14/11/2026 at 06:49

Robert MacDonald-Lewis

I posted this on Facebook the other day and thought it was worth sharing here too:

I've noticed an increasing amount of AI-generated imagery being used to promote fly fishing, fly tying, and similar products. While some of it is initially visually impressive, much of it falls apart under even modest scrutiny.

These include pictures of hands with too many fingers, fish with extra or missing fins, more handles than rods, misaligned scissor blades and handles, illegible text, upside-down text, books with two spines. Flies that look good at first but cannot be tied or fished. This list goes on and on. Other, more subtle examples might escape a beginner but stand out immediately to a more experienced angler or tyer.

Fly fishing and fly tying have a rich history, built on generations of practical experience, craftsmanship, and shared knowledge. There is something fundamentally different between an image, text, or content created by someone who understands their subject and one generated by a system that can imitate its appearance without understanding the details and lacks the knowledge, resulting in mistakes and getting the details wrong.

I am not completely against AI. Used appropriately, it has enormous potential. But I do question whether its increasingly indiscriminate risk is undermining authenticity and devaluing the skills and knowledge that make our sport interesting. Does it devalue the work and effort required to become knowledgeable, reputable, or even an expert?

There should be a responsibility to understand and verify AI-generated content that is published. To me, there is also a question of credibility. If a business or "expert" publishes imagery or text that is obviously incorrect to anyone familiar or knowledgeable with the subject, does this influence the confidence you place in the product, advice or expertise?

I'd be interested to hear what others think.

It feels like we are risking the dilution of knowledge, craftsmanship, and authenticity that are key to fly fishing and fly tying. Do you agree, or is this simply another technology that we should embrace?

Probably more importantly, does it matter to you whether the flies, tackle, and fishing scenes you see in advertising and publications are genuine?

Sandy Nelson

What an excellent post Robert I'm with you all the way on this one I find the use of AI imagery increasingly frustrating and quite annoying in most of its applications . I recently bought the hatch code by Andy Kitchener. Andy is quite clear that he has used AI for many of the images in the book unfortunately it means quite a lot of images are incorrect and the detail that should be there and relate to the real world for people to make proper identifications is incorrect. I think this book in particular is perhaps too big and tries to cover too many subjects so he's had to rely on AI to save time. I see the use of AI as being lazy and as a way of trying to source things that you haven't seen or done yourself. This de-values anything you may have written or created in my eyes and is an increasing trend. On a larger scale and as a view on the wider application, in my opinion because AI is basically glorified search engine I can see that you can apply the rules of Darwin's theory of evolution to it, so that we will end up with a variety of AI who specialise in a particular subject. It stands to reason that If they keep using a Logarithm which will prioritise hits and works on percentages, eventually there will only be one answer to any question. At that point AI becomes useless. I hope.

Although In the meantime it will put many people out of work which is going to screw up most economies, with the turkeys voting for Christmas. I often wonder if it is also driving the push to renewable electricity, just imagine if all the electricity is generated using reliable renewables, then the AIs could run everything like Skynet or the Matrix and just keep a few humans around to fix things, although even some of our primate cousins could probably be trained especially if they had brain implants. Nice idea for a story if it hadn't already been done 😂

Here's hoping that the Tic Tac Toe model from Wargames pans out.

Mike Barrio

Yes, I agree with you guys, it is becoming more than a bit annoying.

"Does this influence the confidence you place in the product, advice or expertise?" Yes, very much so Robert.
And as Sandy says, I think its use can also devalue whatever work or creativity somebody has put into a project.

I can embrace technology, I remember how exciting and interesting I found the early days of the internet, but I think that early creativity by individuals on the web has pretty much gone, replaced by big corporations and monetisation.

Pixar's WALL-E and the line of humans sitting in front of screens on the travelator comes to mind .......

Robert MacDonald-Lewis

Thank you Sandy.

The promotion of the Hatch Code has been prolific and particularly heavy on the use of AI. I haven't bought or seen a physical copy of the book, so I can't comment on its contents. However, my decision not to buy a copy has been influenced by the apparent use of AI and the quality of the promotional material. It would be interesting to know whether AI has also been used in developing the informational content of the book.

The amount of enegry being consumed by AI could be concerning, I was shown a social media post that stated a single AI generated image can use as much enegry as half a smartphone charge, using the least efficient model. At this rate, AI might end up doing more to prolong the life of the oil and gas industry than the industry itself!

Mike Barrio

The Hatch Code was recently reviewed by Martin on Global Flyfisher if you'd like to take a look Robert, see https://globalflyfisher.com/review/hatch-code

James Laraway

So i will dip my toe into this one.

I use a bit of AI in work and it can radically speed up processes as it can scan accross your documents, emails etc so can allow me to do things much much quicker. It also good for if i have written an email and it has the potential to land badly with the recipient and it can tone it down with alternative wording *smiley-lol*

On the other hand i see a lot of people who are not stopping thinking for themselves - which is not good. I see the potential for real dumbing down in future - a bit like kids and smartphones.

In terms of power usage i would rather if there is an excess of power in scotland ( which there is) it was used to lower bills and not be consumed by data centres so people can make dumb pictures or memes

What i do find AI useful for is say i have had trouble with my central heating system which shows an error on a control panel. Give it the make and model and tell it the issue and it will tell you what is wrong. Or when there is a power cut my house alarm warns me every minute that the power is off ( really loudly) - i gave it the make and model and the issue and it told me how to stop it without me having to spend hours reading a manual ( the solution it came up with took about 30 secs) So there is good and bad

As for renewables they have their place but we will need oil and gas for years so lets use our own for goodness sake.....it creates energy security , well paid jobs and much needed tax


Barrio Fly Lines - designed in Scotland - Cast with confidence all over the world

Barrio Fly Lines

Designed in Scotland

Manufactured in the UK

Cast with confidence all over the world

www.flylineshop.com